Can fixing up an old gas car be the key to a cleaner, fairer future for first-time drivers? While EVs are celebrated for their low emissions during use, their production imposes significant environmental and social costs, including lithium mining that depletes water supplies, harms ecosystems, and disproportionately impacts vulnerable communities. At the same time, older gas cars are often prematurely scrapped, wasting resources that could be salvaged through repair and reuse. This study combines historical research on vehicle recycling trends and correlational analysis of emissions data to compare the sustainability of EV production with the repair of older gas cars. Using emissions statistics, data on first-time drivers, and recycling efficiencies, the research employs coding techniques to identify key trade-offs, supported by visual aids like emissions graphs. By challenging the assumption that "new" is always better, this research will reveal how repairing older cars can reduce waste, lower emissions, and promote equity—offering first-time drivers a practical, affordable, and sustainable alternative.